| Player | Outscored % |
|---|---|
| Chris Warren | 74.35% |
| Bill Miller | 66.28% |
| Ryan Sykes | 62.83% |
| David Taylor | 62.60% |
| Allen Rash | 56.28% |
| John Redo | 55.50% |
| Mike Gray | 54.49% |
| Steve Baker | 53.27% |
| Jen Miller | 53.16% |
| Duane Connell | 50.75% |
| Leo Miller | 49.25% |
| Mike O'Brien | 48.11% |
| Jess Sykes | 46.92% |
| Rick Pecot | 46.79% |
| Andrew Leopin | 46.38% |
| Xander Sykes | 43.53% |
| Ronnie Whitworth | 37.93% |
| Kyle Chamberlin | 36.80% |
| Alicia Whitman | 36.43% |
| Zac Talley | 36.24% |
| Justin Wade | 33.71% |
| Meredith Brown | 19.99% |